Himanshu SharmaSoftware engineer
Let’s talk

AI Search: AEO and GEO · Lesson 9 of 20

Original information and first-hand experience

Why commodity content gives AI systems no reason to cite you, and how to add original data, first-hand detail and genuine expertise without inventing anything.

11 minWriting, entities and trustUpdated 14 November 2026

Awaiting technical review. This lesson is readable but not yet listed in search engines.

By the end of this lessonIdentify commodity content on your own pages and add genuinely original, verifiable information and first-hand experience.

The one recommendation that outlasts tactics

After this lesson you can look at your own page and say honestly: "what here exists only because we wrote it?" Then you can add it.

Google's generative AI guide (2026-05) puts unique, non-commodity, first-hand content at the centre, and Google's announcement says that this kind of content will likely matter more over time than any other suggestion. That is documented as Google's stated view. Whether it determines a particular citation cannot be known from outside.

What commodity content is

If ten pages say the same thing in similar words, any one of them is replaceable. An AI summary needs only one source, or none. "What is a mortgage" explained in generic terms by a small bakery's blog adds no reason to choose that page.

Commodity content isn't bad. Basic definitions help beginners. The problem is relying on it as your only asset.

What original looks like

Original information comes from something real. Here are honest forms, with fictional examples:

  • Your own measurements. A bookshop timing how long its own orders take to ship over a month, with the method stated.
  • First-hand testing. A tutoring service describing what changed when it moved from weekly to twice-weekly sessions for its own students, with caveats about sample size.
  • Local or specific knowledge. A bakery explaining how humidity in its own kitchen changes proof times.
  • Original images, screenshots, diagrams you made, with captions that explain them.
  • A clear point of view after real consideration, labelled as opinion.
  • Primary documents you collected: forms, price lists you are entitled to publish, interview notes you recorded with permission.

The rule: you could show your work if asked. If you could not, it does not belong.

Experience in the text

A common beginner problem is claiming experience without showing it. Compare:

text
Weak:  "Our experts have years of experience baking bread."
Better: "We feed our starter at 7am and 7pm. In winter the kitchen sits near 16 degrees and the dough needs about two extra hours."

The second contains details only someone who did it would think to say. Do not copy that example's numbers; use your own true ones. If there are no true details yet, collect them before writing.

What never to do

  • Invent a number, quote, review, credential, client or case study. The course rule applies to this course and to you.
  • Present someone else's research as your own.
  • Paraphrase another page line by line. Search engines and readers can tell, and Google's spam guidance covers scraped and lightly rewritten content.
  • Publish large volumes of AI-generated pages without anything of your own in them. Google's spam policies treat scaled low-value content as abuse regardless of how it is produced.

AI-assisted writing

Google's guide says Search's usual essentials apply to AI-assisted content. Using a tool to draft or tidy is not in itself the problem; publishing unchecked text is. If you use one: check every fact against a source, remove anything you cannot verify, add your own material, and be accountable for the page as the author. Never let a model supply "experience" you did not have.

A practical method: the evidence column

Before writing a page, make a two-column table: claim and evidence.

Claim Evidence I actually have
Starter doubles in about 4 hours at kitchen temperature My own log for 14 days
Whole-wheat flour ferments faster A comparison I ran, photos kept
Best flour brand No evidence; leave it out

Claims without evidence are cut or labelled as opinion. Use the word counter to see how much of the page is repeated generic explanation versus your own material.

This site

This site's lessons currently carry status review: a human, Himanshu, still has to check each course. The original contribution here is limited to what he adds, such as real examples from his own work, and he must supply true facts. This lesson does not claim any.

Common mistakes

  • Equating "original" with "different words".
  • Adding a fake "founder story" to seem authentic.
  • Citing "studies" without naming a source you have read.
  • Publishing dozens of near-identical city or product pages with swapped names.
  • Hiding your method. Without it, readers cannot judge a number.

Exercise

  1. Pick one page. Highlight each paragraph green (only you could write this), yellow (useful but generic) or red (could be anyone's). Count the colours.
  2. For two yellow paragraphs, write down what real experience, measurement or example you could add.
  3. Gather the evidence (photos, logs, notes) before rewriting.
Show a sample answer

A typical first result is mostly yellow. That is normal. The goal is not an all-green page, but at least one section that genuinely cannot be found elsewhere, such as a tested method, a dataset or a documented local fact.

Previous: Headings, lists, tables and FAQs. Next: Entities, brand mentions and consistency.

Key points

  • Google's generative AI guide names original, first-hand, non-commodity content as the most important recommendation for the long run.
  • Commodity content repeats what is already everywhere; it gives a reader or a system little reason to prefer your page.
  • Original means things you actually did, measured, observed or know, not rewording of other pages.
  • Never invent experience, data or quotes; being caught is worse than being plain.
  • Use AI writing tools only with human checking; Search's rules apply to AI-assisted content.

Check yourself

1. What does 'commodity content' mean here?
2. Which is genuinely first-hand?
3. A writer invents a customer quote to add credibility. What is the problem?
4. What does Google's guide say about AI-assisted content?

Free tools for this lesson